Log in

View Full Version : U.S. mom sues $19,000 a-year preschool for being "big playground" U.S. mom sues presc


ShyGuyInChicago
March 17th, 2011, 04:18 PM
http://www.fox8.com/sns-rt-lawsuit-preschooln14172744-20110314,0,2053413,full.story

NEW YORK, March 14 (Reuters Life!) - A mother in New York
is suing her 4-year-old daughter's posh preschool, calling it
"one big playroom" that deprived the child of the edge needed
to get into an elite elementary school.

Caught up in New York City's "insanely competitive" nursery
school scene, Nicole Imprescia said she paid $19,000 annual
tuition to York Avenue Preschool and wants it back, according
to her lawsuit that was filed late on Friday.

Her daughter, Lucia, was two years old when she was
enrolled in the Upper East Side neighborhood school.

Imprescia said she heard the school's sales pitch and was
hooked by the promise it would help Lucia on her E.R.B, a
standardized test used for admission to the city's most
competitive public and private kindergartens.

But instead of prepping Lucia to nail the test by the time
she was four, York Avenue "dumped" her with children as young
as two who were learning about shapes and colors, the lawsuit
said.

"Indeed, the school proved not to be a school at all, but
just one big playroom," according to the lawsuit, which claims
Imprescia was deceived and defrauded.

A toddler who takes the wrong first step could ultimately
trip up his or her chances for acceptance into an Ivy League
college and for earning a higher income, it said.

"There is tremendous pressure to choose the right
preschool," it said.

The lawsuit was filed in the weeks after many elite
elementary schools send out their acceptance and rejection
letters.

An attorney for Imprescia, Mathew Paulose, Jr., said the
child was pulled out of the pre-school in October 2010, close
to the start of the school year and, therefore, the full
tuition should be returned.

"It's a case of theft. They promised certain things but it
turned out to be another thing," Paulose said.

An attorney for York Avenue Preschool was not immediately
available for comment.
(Reporting by Barbara Goldberg; Editing by Ellen Wulfhorst and
Jerry Norton)

Personally, I would never spend this much money on pre-school even if I could afford it.

Magus
March 17th, 2011, 05:06 PM
Horrors of Capitalism and privatized education.

Sage
March 17th, 2011, 05:15 PM
I will agree with the woman on this single thing: That pre-school is theft, and I commend them for going after people with large wallets and miniature brains.

scuba steve
March 17th, 2011, 06:25 PM
What did she honestly expect was going to be happening, Algebra classes?

ShyGuyInChicago
March 17th, 2011, 06:30 PM
What did she honestly expect was going to be happening, Algebra classes?

The mom said that she was under the impression that going to school will prepare her for Ivy League universities.

Fact
March 17th, 2011, 06:32 PM
Horrors of Capitalism and privatized education.

No: the horrors of people with more money than sense.

Sage
March 17th, 2011, 08:24 PM
No: the horrors of people with more money than sense.

As in, capitalism.

Sith Lord 13
March 18th, 2011, 09:11 AM
Believe it or not, the mother was doing the right thing. Do you do SAT prep? You should. Then prep for high school entrance exams. Now prepping for elementary entrance exams. Each step before helps the next one.

Quick_Sylver
March 18th, 2011, 12:13 PM
Believe it or not, the mother was doing the right thing. Do you do SAT prep? You should. Then prep for high school entrance exams. Now prepping for elementary entrance exams. Each step before helps the next one.

Yeah, in a way I agree with this a bit. However, What the fuck? The kid is HOW old? Kids need that playground, not chemical sciences. =/ I get wanting a good education for your kids, but really? Kids need a childhood. Taking it away like that is wrong to me.

Sith Lord 13
March 18th, 2011, 02:44 PM
Yeah, in a way I agree with this a bit. However, What the fuck? The kid is HOW old? Kids need that playground, not chemical sciences. =/ I get wanting a good education for your kids, but really? Kids need a childhood. Taking it away like that is wrong to me.

There needs to be balance, absolutely.

LozziRAWR
March 18th, 2011, 04:25 PM
I went to a community pre-school, then a crappy primary(elementary) school with no proper headmistress or teachers that werent on supply, and i turned out pretty good.
if she thinks her FOUR YEAR OLD kid isnt getting good education she should start working with her at home IMO

UnknownError
March 18th, 2011, 05:08 PM
Lmao where I stay the closed to pre-school you get is a free drop in toddlers with some mats, toy cars and a bike or two where the mums talk and the kids play for a hour. :P
Then nursery which is free Im sure (Well obvs taxes and shit but let's not go into that.)

Woman needs to understand it's a four year old, not a 18 year old. :L

LozziRAWR
March 18th, 2011, 05:11 PM
Woman needs to understand it's a four year old, not a 18 year old. :L

Exactly, the first few years of a kids life are supposed to be getting used to sights+sounds and stuff like that, not learning stuff that they arent gonna use for another 12 years :O

CaptainObvious
March 18th, 2011, 05:37 PM
welcome to rich people in manhattan, ladies and gentlemen. this is the hysteria wrought among the rich by meritocracy. on the other hand... if the result is producing smart kids, that's fine with me. america needs more.

Believe it or not, the mother was doing the right thing. Do you do SAT prep? You should. Then prep for high school entrance exams. Now prepping for elementary entrance exams. Each step before helps the next one.

i have never studied for a standardized test in my life. what an absolute waste of time.

Sage
March 18th, 2011, 08:49 PM
if the result is producing smart kids, that's fine with me. america needs more.

The smartest people are those that are motivated to pursue knowledge and education themselves. Imposing rigorous prep programs on children is unnecessary.

CaptainObvious
March 18th, 2011, 09:03 PM
The smartest people are those that are motivated to pursue knowledge and education themselves. Imposing rigorous prep programs on children is unnecessary.

that's definitely true (well, at least the first part), but it seems to me that it's unlikely to make things worse so i don't see it as tragic, you know?

Sage
March 18th, 2011, 09:34 PM
but it seems to me that it's unlikely to make things worse so i don't see it as tragic, you know?

Well, that's certainly fair.

scuba steve
March 18th, 2011, 09:51 PM
Then nursery which is free Im sure (Well obvs taxes and shit but let's not go into that.)


No, no, no, no... Deffinately not, nursery is very expensive. It's bascially just paying for a babysitter, a baby sitter with an expensive lifestyle. Your talking hundreds of Pounds per month.

AndrewwnnaAbigail
March 19th, 2011, 01:17 AM
parents will often spend a significant amount of money on educating their kids (http://www.newsytype.com/4924-190000-lawsuit-preschool/). For several families, the amount of money spent on educating their kids can run to the millions. One Manhattan mother is suing a preschool for $19,000 -- the cost of yearly tuition that she paid to the school. The mother boasts the preschool didn't teach her daughter what was advertised.

Sith Lord 13
March 19th, 2011, 07:29 AM
welcome to rich people in manhattan, ladies and gentlemen. this is the hysteria wrought among the rich by meritocracy. on the other hand... if the result is producing smart kids, that's fine with me. america needs more.

Agreed with the second part.

i have never studied for a standardized test in my life. what an absolute waste of time.

Same here (unless you count one practice exam so as not to have to waste time reading the instructions on test day). That doesn't mean others won't benefit from it.

The smartest people are those that are motivated to pursue knowledge and education themselves. Imposing rigorous prep programs on children is unnecessary.

Agreed with the first part but the proper start can instill that in children. Some always will and some never will but some have the potential to be that way if given the proper start.