What is your favorite song from Animals?

[The Joker]

I'm tired of everyone giving a blowjob to Sheep.

YZD1hPJG-B8

[Amnesiac]

Dogs, Pigs and Sheep are all equally epic in their own special ways. Personally, I prefer Sheep for the guitar licks, synthesized vocals, keyboard solo and Bible verse:

j5mJQGMqJvw

[deadpie]

Dogs. Also, this thread is pretty useless. About seven or less users like this album and it's not even Pink Floyd's best.

[Sugaree]

Fuck yeah Pigs.

Tim's right. Not many on here have heard this album, not even the best of Pink Floyd. If someone started a Dark Side of the Moon thread, it'd get a few more replies.

[deadpie]

Fuck yeah Pigs.

Tim's right. Not many on here have heard this album, not even the best of Pink Floyd. If someone started a Dark Side of the Moon thread, it'd get a few more replies.

>Implying Dark Side is their best album

>Implying people didn't know Echoes on here until I posted it fifty times a couple months ago

[Peace God]

Sheep...because i love the intro.

[Amnesiac]

>Implying people didn't know Echoes on here until I posted it fifty times a couple months ago

>implying I haven't been listening to Echoes for years and years

[deadpie]

>implying I haven't been listening to Echoes for years and years

>Implying listening to Pink Floyd proves you have good music taste

[Amnesiac]

>Implying listening to Pink Floyd proves you have good music taste

>implying I implied it means I have good musical taste
>implying musical taste isn't an opinion

[deadpie]

>implying I implied it means I have good musical taste
>implying musical taste isn't an opinion

You obviously don't notice how much you talk about Pink Floyd and OK Computer here on VT.

And good musical taste is based on levels of understanding music itself. Knowing that music isn't limited to certain type of instruments or that you have to fit inside a genre. Good music taste is one that is open to something that experiments or is willing to not sound the same. That's kind of part of music theory.

[Fact]

I listened to Pigs and enjoyed it, having said that I've not listened to any of the other songs on the album so I'm unable to compare between them >.<

[Amnesiac]

You obviously don't notice how much you talk about Pink Floyd and OK Computer here on VT.

And good musical taste is based on levels of understanding music itself. Knowing that music isn't limited to certain type of instruments or that you have to fit inside a genre. Good music taste is one that is open to something that experiments or is willing to not sound the same. That's kind of part of music theory.

I'll be the first to admit that my musical tastes are relatively narrow, which is why I don't spam here in the Music section as much as others.

Also, that's a different definition of "taste", but I guess it works just as well.

[Sugaree]

>go check on Animals thread
>see a debate on Pink Floyd
>post better Pink Floyd songs

zSeGrrg-u0w
>Ummagumma, underrated Pink Floyd

7Wkk--2St3E
>Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, Syd-era that no one cares about

B201O63uqhk
>Division Bell, should have been released as a single, Rick Wright on lead vocal, most beautiful Pink Floyd song

xT2VPk2Y9mk&fmt=18
>Momentary Lapse Of Reason, best post-Waters solo

2e-yO6_FbtI
>The Final Cut, gets a lot of shit thrown at it but this is a gem in the rough, most emotional Floyd song and it would have sounded AMAZING live

[deadpie]

The Final Cut is what Roger Waters wanted as The Wall Pt. 2. Another reason why I hate it.

Also, Roger Waters & David Gilmour after PF:

UzX_zPSrqcQ

Gdansk is still my favorite live CD/DVD of all time. OF ALL TIME.

uMijMWQlnUc

I think "Amused To Death" is easily the best political albums that goes deep into philosophical lyrics also. It's Waters' best work to date and probably will always be. I'd probably enjoy this album allot more if I didn't have a hatred for Waters' personality.
Also, the lyrics to this song are perfect. Amazing live performance too.


BTW: If you ever plan to see David Gilmour live, don't expect to hear Echoes. Ever. He's said he won't play the song now ever sense Richard Wright passed, which is completely understandable. That's probably why I feel allot more emotion towards the Gdansk version because it feels like his last moments were also a great part of the instrumentation of that song in the live performance.

tl;dr pink floyd fanboy fapping to prog rock.

inb4 who's richard wright

[Sugaree]

The Final Cut is what Roger Waters wanted as The Wall Pt. 2. Another reason why I hate it.

Considering that TFC started out as a soundtrack to 'The Wall' movie, I'm not surprised. But I still like it. The only problem is that Gilmour gets a total of one vocal lead when he could have easily done more. The sad part is that it's basically Waters' first solo album, it isn't really Floyd. There are exceptions on this album however that provide a good amount of emotion like "Southampton Dock", "The Final Cut", "Two Suns In The Sunset", and "The Post-War Dream". tl;dr fanboy defending The Final Cut

Also, Roger Waters & David Gilmour after PF:

UzX_zPSrqcQ

Gdansk is still my favorite live CD/DVD of all time. OF ALL TIME.

I'm still neutral on Gdansk. I've listened to it many times over, but I like the entire 'On An Island' performance.


BTW: If you ever plan to see David Gilmour live, don't expect to hear Echoes. Ever. He's said he won't play the song now ever sense Richard Wright passed, which is completely understandable. That's probably why I feel allot more emotion towards the Gdansk version because it feels like his last moments were also a great part of the instrumentation of that song in the live performance.


>seeing David Gilmour live

lol not gonna happen. I think Gilmour is done, solo and Pink Floyd wise. A shame, but it was bound to happen. Seems that Nick Mason is feeling the same. I agree with not performing 'Echoes' again. It wouldn't be the same without Richard. His playing and singing made that song.

[deadpie]

lol not gonna happen. I think Gilmour is done, solo and Pink Floyd wise. A shame, but it was bound to happen. Seems that Nick Mason is feeling the same. I agree with not performing 'Echoes' again. It wouldn't be the same without Richard. His playing and singing made that song.

>Implying he didn't just collaborate on an album called "The Orb".

[Sugaree]

>Implying he didn't just collaborate on an album called "The Orb".

>implying it wasn't called "Metallic Spheres"

[deadpie]

>implying it wasn't called "Metallic Spheres"

>Implying I remembered/cared.

The album wasn't that good anyways. Sounded like walking into a gay bar and getting fucked by a dick in every position possible.