Log in

View Full Version : School Forces Student to Remove American Flag Shirt


Maverick
September 25th, 2008, 04:26 PM
School Forces Student to Remove American Flag Shirt

Danielle Gaines
The Merced Sun Star
September 23, 2008

Students at Dos Palos High School protested Thursday — by wearing patriotic regalia to school — after a sophomore student was forced to remove a T-shirt depicting the American flag.

Officials at the Merced County school confirmed Thursday that Jake Shelly was forced to take off a red, white and blue tie-dyed American flag T-shirt on Tuesday. The shirt said nothing offensive, just: “United States of America, Washington, D.C.”

The school’s assistant principal issued Shelly a bright yellow T-shirt that read “DCV: Dress Code Violator” to wear for the rest of the day. He was given his shirt back after classes ended.

“It was really embarrassing and humiliating to have to wear that all day — and just for supporting your country,” his sister Kaycee Shelly said.

Kaycee Shelly told members of the media at lunchtime that her brother was overwhelmed and did not want to do any more interviews.

Earlier in the day, he was speaking with a local news station when an unidentified teacher walked up to him, ripped off the microphone clipped to his shirt and told him he was not allowed to talk to the media.

District officials said they apologized to the student, his family and the local American Legion on Wednesday — Constitution Day.

“In reviewing the dress code at the time, an administrator felt the shirt was in violation of that section of the dress code,” said Superintendent Brian Walker. “She asked him to remove it and he did.”

The assistant principal initially thought Shelly’s T-shirt violated a clause of the school dress code that does not allow “shirts/blouses that promote specific races, cultures, or ethnicities.”

School officials said they will now interpret that clause of the dress code — which was written at the beginning of this school year — differently.

Defiance when asked to remove an article of clothing is an automatic 3- to 5-day suspension, according to the dress code.

“Certainly we are taking responsibility for it and it will not happen again,” Walker said. “A shirt that has an American flag, a shirt that has a Chinese flag or a Mexican flag, is certainly not a violation of that part of the dress code.”

Jake Shelly was wearing the tie-dyed T-shirt as part of a hippie dress-up day during homecoming week.

Students on campus started a campaign to wear as much red, white or blue clothing and carry as many flags as possible Thursday in protest of Tuesday’s decision, despite the apology. Jake Shelly wore the same shirt he wore Tuesday and was not disciplined.

“I am glad so many people are supporting this and wearing red, white and blue,” his sister said. She believes the swift change in rules was because of the overwhelming student action.

A.J. Galindo is one student who wore a patriotic shirt to school.

Galindo’s shirt honored Marine Cpl. Joshua Pickard, a family member who died in Iraq in 2006. Pickard’s two brothers remain active in the Marines.

“I think it is horrible that you can’t wear an American flag to school without something like this happening,” he said, referring to the flurry of activities during the school’s lunch hour. “We have people fighting for our country and dying every day, but we can’t wear an American flag at a public school?”

A.J. said he was proud of the patriotism displayed by his classmates.

His mother, Julie, said she was upset when she first heard the news Tuesday but feels better about the situation now.

“Initially, I was really concerned about what I heard, but after asking a few questions I realized the whole controversy is just the result of one person’s misinterpretation of the rule,” she said.

Julie Galindo said everyone makes mistakes and accepted the apologies by the school’s administration.

She added that Dos Palos is a patriotic town and erected a veteran’s memorial just last year. Several members of the education community served on a committee to erect the memorial that stands on the grounds of Marks Elementary School.

“I wouldn’t want anyone to think of Dos Palos as an unpatriotic place,” Julie Galindo said. “I feel very proud of my town and very proud of my country and very proud to wear the American flag.”

Gumleaf
September 25th, 2008, 04:49 PM
hmmmm, the joys of being politically correct!!!

Oblivion
September 25th, 2008, 05:33 PM
That's so dumb
People need to calm down
Both sides- He shouldn't have been made to take it off, but at the same time, it's not that big of a deal.

Serenity
September 25th, 2008, 06:14 PM
Wow.
What a retarded admin.
[at the school, not Ant :P]

How could you ever think that would be against the dress code?? Seriously? Stupid people make me so angry.

0=
September 25th, 2008, 09:09 PM
In a way it's disrespectful. The flag is supposed to be a sacred thing. You take care of it, fold it, don't let it touch the ground, raise and lower it with respect, and when it's old, dirty, and tattered you retire it in a solemn cremation ceremony. It can easily be interpreted as disrespectful to wear such a sacred and honored thing around: getting it dirty, spilling ketchup from your lunch on it, letting it be ripped by everyday use, and throwing it in your smelly laundry pile at the end of the day.

Oblivion
September 25th, 2008, 09:13 PM
It wasn't a real flag though...
That's like suggesting having a cremations ceremony for all the USA flag bumper stickers, patches, pins, stickers, anything.

0=
September 25th, 2008, 09:29 PM
It wasn't a real flag though...
That's like suggesting having a cremations ceremony for all the USA flag bumper stickers, patches, pins, stickers, anything.

I really think our country is too nationalistic. It's beyond being patriotic. It doesn't make sense to me to use all those products you mentioned.

iJack
September 25th, 2008, 09:30 PM
Make the administrator wear the bright yellow T-shirt that read “DCV: Dress Code Violator” for a day, adn not be able to go into his office, or hide for more that 10 minutes.

Serenity
September 25th, 2008, 11:49 PM
It can easily be interpreted as disrespectful to wear such a sacred and honored thing around

It'd be one thing if that was the reasoning the guy used. But no, he said it violated dress code b/c they don't allow “shirts/blouses that promote specific races, cultures, or ethnicities.”

If it was a respect the flag argument, I might be able to agree with it. But no, it was pretty much just a matter of stupidity.

Zephyr
September 26th, 2008, 12:34 AM
Riiiiiiiight.

That's the most retarded dress code I've ever heard of.
What happened to freedom of speech?
If that EVER happened in my public school district,
That administrator would have been toast or pretty damn close to it.

japanman
September 26th, 2008, 01:15 AM
*prints out japans flag and sew it onto shirt and wears it to school* xP

O and here is my impression of what happened

*ahem*

Big dum meany principal person guy: You no wear amereecan flag it is breaking rule!!

Smart cool student person: But sir your completely incoorect, How could this possible violate dress code 2.334.

Big dum meany principal person guy: Uhh wha does violate mean.....SUSPENSION

ten days lader and Big dum meany principal person guy finally fixs the dress code rule and leaves Smart cool student person alone.

ShatteredWings
September 26th, 2008, 06:01 AM
o.O wow

people are stupid :yes:

Whisper
September 26th, 2008, 06:36 AM
Bitch should be fired
and if anyone stormed up to me a ripped a mic off of me i'd charge them with assault

Callwaiting
September 29th, 2008, 05:00 AM
I guess it could be interpreted badly depending on who was wearing it and how they were acting.
But patriotism has gone way too far - people blindly support Bush because he leads America. The attitudes of a lot of people are "America is best, screw everyone else" and when worn by one of those people I think it'd be doing everyone a favour to take it off.