Log in

View Full Version : sudden/false breakup with odd relationship?


kittycat72
June 25th, 2016, 02:03 AM
Alright, first off, thank you for seeing if you can help me at all, but i'll just say first off that this is a complicated huge relationship thing, but i'll try to put the history in brief.

PAST:
OK, so there is a girl who I really like (I think I'm in love, but I'm still in high school so maybe I don't know the true definition of love), and in middle school, she told me she liked me. I didn't know what she meant at the time, but late middle school, I realized I had feelings for her, and I told her, and she said she still had feelings for me also, but the problem was she had a boyfriend by that time. I think the reason why they got together was because he got her at her most vulnerable part of her life, right when her parents were going through a divorce. So he played the part of the comforting companion. Starting freshman year of high school, it was safe to say me and her liked one another romantically, and she even said at some point that she sometime wishes that she went out with me instead of her boyfriend currently. She also said that if everything was a blank slate, and she had the option to choose between me and her boyfriend to go out with, she would choose me easily. This made me feel really close with her, hence partially why I feel so attached to her. She every now and then complements me in a romantic way, and shes wanted to kiss me, and we plan on doing it at these parties I have, but the past two times either I didn't know what she wanted me to do (I felt so stupid lmao) or that I didn't know I was supposed to be the one making moves. We've stayed up for several hours through out nights and days skyping, playing agar.io, and I'm almost certain that we both enjoyed it. Now that's the past. Here's the drastic present :<

PRESENT: A month ago, she started acting odd the morning after a skype call that ended pretty happily. She asked that morning if we could just be friends and talk like friends rather than secret lovers. So in short, she was friend-zoning me. I tried to talk her out of it and reason with her, but she turned into a forceful thing then. I kept asking if she still had feelings, she said it doesn't matter and that she had loved me, which really broke my heart because she never before said she loved me, until now, but she said it past tense so its bad also. The reason she was doing this all was because she has heavy guilt because shes sorta kinda cheating with her boyfriend by keeping me as her secret lover (I know I don't like the fact that shes cheating on him with me, but to be honest, I seriously feel like I can't live without her and I can't just turn to some other girl because no one else is the same as her. Also I want to point out that her and her boyfriend get into fights constantly and I feel bad for her.). Eventually, I forgot how, we went back to normal after several days or so (maybe 5-7 days) and she seemed good again. We got back to our regular relationship status, plus even more because she started sometimes saying in skype calls "I love you" or tried saying something heavily implying those words, but specifically said she can't say them because shes not allowed to, but she does want to say them. So pretty much, she did love me. I just want to point out that she took some of this relationship stuff pretty far with things like suggestive pictures and stuff, and I didn't ask for most, she just literally wanted to lol. But alright. So everything seems great, right? NOWWWW heres the drastic drastic present present.

PRESENT PRESENT: Last week, she was getting extra annoyed at my constant "spamming" and that when she doesn't reply, I used to say she was ignoring me (because she would stay on other things and do other things, but not reply until like 10 minutes later). It turned into pretty heated for her, and in fact she blocked me on Skype, Instagram, Xbox, and IMessage. My only form of communication was to snapchat her, which after a decent amount of apologizing and waiting a day or so, we we're back to normal and she unblocked me and stuff. Then we were "ok". Something didn't feel right because she wasn't acting super normal and she was very picky on me over messaging. Eventually, I asked her what was wrong and she said that she gets stressed out when I mix love into our conversations and then her guilt makes her angry. So I suggested that we keep emotions 100% tucked away, and she said that was good. Then I realized that could be kinda sad for me, so I said I didn't know, so she skyped me for the first time in a week or so, and she immediately said that she didn't have feelings for me, but she used to. Dang. I hung up because she was serious and I couldn't keep talking like that, so I messaged her "So you want him, period?" referring to her boyfriend. She said yes, and so I broke :D I started cursing her sorta out and her boyfriend and telling her how much pain she's causing me. We kept going, her acting like "I was taking this too dramatically", and we fought. I kept asking why, or was she serious, and she said yes she was serious, and she wouldn't say why. She also at one point almost started intentional over doing the drama. But it soon became serious. She wouldn't take most of it seriously at all. She acted like it was a big game. She kept saying "lol" or "lmao" or seeming like she was trying to intentionally make it less serious. The next day I kept asking why and what not and to give me another chance or to think about it, and she said no, she won't change her mind. She then said she never liked me, and so I asked what about previously, and she acted confused and said "she liked me as a friend" and "she loves me like a friend" and keeps trying to act like nothing happened and wants me as a best friend, which I understand why, but she let me down too harshly. She kept telling me to stop talking to her and to quit messaging her and to leave her alone. I kept begging for forgiveness and she didn't care. Literally, she said she didn't care, and she did the same blocking as previously. Today, I made some headway and she said she was done with how I've been acting towards her, and I apologized for recent things, and she said its not even the recent stuff, but all the time how I treat her, saying that she tells me to stop things I do, and I don't (I don't recall anything like that...?). I tell her that I can fix it, and she says I can't, so I tell her to let me act better for tonight to show her I can do better, and she replies instantly with "leave me alone" so I say I'll leave her alone, but if she could think about it, then that'd be great. She then replies saying in caps to leave her alone and that shes done with my bs and she hasn't even read half of the large messages I've sent her expressing my feelings and apologies. heh. That's how far it goes. Then tomorrow (Saturday) I have a friend's birthday party at the movies with 5 other girls, Including the girl I've been talking about is going to be there with her best friends. She previously said to sit by her at the movies so we can "talk about it" and she said this while she was saying she she didn't like me and kept screaming it at me, so I'm guessing all she'd do at the movies is just make my day and tell me it straight to my face. I definitely don't feel comfortable especially with her around trying to act like nothing happened.

FINALLYYYYY, my FINAL QUESTIONS: Alright, THANK YOUUU if you actually read any of that lol but ok, so my final concerns are:

1. She doesn't act this weird before. Is she really serious? Or is this just a thing with her guilty stuff? I suspect personally this is just temporary like the previous situation a month ago, but it wasn't this bad either. (FYI she is moderately religious, hence her super wanting to not sin)

2. How should I deal with it? (if you say to let her go, honestly I don't think I can do that.)

3. Should I go to the movies tomorrow with her and her friends (Saturday)? If I should, what should I do? She seems like she wants me to go to the movies so that I don't hurt her friend in not going because it's her friend's birthday. She doesn't really seem like she cares if I go for her own self. She said if I want to, I don't have to talk to her the whole time.

THANK YOU SOOOOOOOOO MUCH FOR READING
I hope you can help me out. Sorry I had to put so much text. I'm better at putting too much rather than too little. Thank you again!

Cygnus
June 25th, 2016, 03:04 AM
Alright, time to get serious for a bit.

1. She's either most likely very very confused or has settled her mind towards her current relationship for however longer it lasts. I feel that when there's such a strong friendship (whatever you'd call it) over the years that doesn't just fade away overnight, she's probably trying to "fake it till she makes it" so she can settle with her current boyfriend for now because man, it's not easy to be torn over two people, no matter who you are or what the situation is. Put yourself in her perspective and imagine how hard it must be to have feelings for two people and live in a world where you have to choose one of two people you're really fond of and you really admire.

2. I believe that for now, whilst not letting her go, you should set it aside and be supportive of her. You can get into trouble with her current boyfriend if he finds out (especially since you mentioned suggestive pictures) and that will NOT end well in any way shape or form. Avoid a fight at all costs, again, put yourself in her perspective and see two guys she really admires fighting, how much will that hurt for her? While not losing hopes of being something with her in future time consider that she will see you being supportive right now as a sign of maturity, it'll speak a lot about you, keep being friends and just don't pressure her. No one likes to be under pressure. A wise man called Mike (ImCoolBeans on VT) told me that if it is meant to be, it will be man. Don't pressure her and if there really is love it'll arise once more, if they break up you will still be there being her friend and that's what really counts.

3. Yes. If she wants to talk you talk. If you want to talk to her, talk, be direct. And have fun man! It's a damn movie just watch the movie, enjoy, and leave early if you really have to.

kittycat72
June 25th, 2016, 01:36 PM
Alright, time to get serious for a bit.

1. She's either most likely very very confused or has settled her mind towards her current relationship for however longer it lasts. I feel that when there's such a strong friendship (whatever you'd call it) over the years that doesn't just fade away overnight, she's probably trying to "fake it till she makes it" so she can settle with her current boyfriend for now because man, it's not easy to be torn over two people, no matter who you are or what the situation is. Put yourself in her perspective and imagine how hard it must be to have feelings for two people and live in a world where you have to choose one of two people you're really fond of and you really admire.

2. I believe that for now, whilst not letting her go, you should set it aside and be supportive of her. You can get into trouble with her current boyfriend if he finds out (especially since you mentioned suggestive pictures) and that will NOT end well in any way shape or form. Avoid a fight at all costs, again, put yourself in her perspective and see two guys she really admires fighting, how much will that hurt for her? While not losing hopes of being something with her in future time consider that she will see you being supportive right now as a sign of maturity, it'll speak a lot about you, keep being friends and just don't pressure her. No one likes to be under pressure. A wise man called Mike (ImCoolBeans on VT) told me that if it is meant to be, it will be man. Don't pressure her and if there really is love it'll arise once more, if they break up you will still be there being her friend and that's what really counts.

3. Yes. If she wants to talk you talk. If you want to talk to her, talk, be direct. And have fun man! It's a damn movie just watch the movie, enjoy, and leave early if you really have to.

Thank you so much for the reply and especially that you answered the my questions, but that is actually very helpful for my situation. My only concern is that she doesn't really reply unless I ask her a number of times to please reply back, and I'm concerned about the movie. I tried asking her if she's just going to rub in my face that she hates me if I sat next to her and went to the movie, and she read and ignored my message. I tried asking again just a bit ago but she hasn't replied. I know it may sound like i'm being a little harsh, but I can't help it much. Part of me wants to go and sit next to her during the movie and "hope for the best", but the other part of me doesn't want to go at all because I think she's just trying to lure me out or something so that she can bash my face in (not literally of course). Another problem is that when going to this bday party, I'll be in her domain because all the people there are girls, and they're all besties with each other, but not really me and the only people I know is the birthday person and the girl this is all about. I'm still torn on that issue. Do you have any suggestions? Thank again!

kittycat72
June 30th, 2016, 11:16 PM
UPDATE (reminder, this is all happening over text): welp she sorta got super mad and wanted me to fix all these problems I was supposedly causing, and in return (I thought) she would consider going back to having feelings for me. WELLLL turned out she meant she would just let me be friends with her if I did all that. So when I was angry and texted I didn't want to be friends with her at the moment because she just broke my heart, she called me a lustful pig and stuff because I only wanted her for lustful reasons. she also that whole time was sending screenshots to her bf and her best girl friend and was telling them that I was trying to tell her to cheat on her bf with me (which obviously wasn't true.) We had a super final fight/argument/yelling spree, and then she blocked me on everything again, and I did likewise. That night I send a super long message sorta cursing her out, sorta explaining that it wasn't nice to say I did things I didn't do. It's been probably about a little under a week since that's happened. I really miss her old self and I feel like I should forget about her, and I've asked around for advice and they've said to ignore her back or to give up on her. Part of me has hope she still likes me and this is all just to see how far she can push me and then see me running back begging on my knees. Should I set up a mutual speaking grounds on snapchat or something so she can't screenshot, or should I just continue ignoring her? What do you think?