If you could...

[Professional Russian]

If you could take any member from any band and make a band out of just those people who would you pick and why?

Heres mine:
Freddie Mercury:Vocals: You cant beet him when it comes to vocals
Brian May: Guitarist: its Brian May everyone loves that hair
David Gilmour: Guitarist #2 David Gilmour Becasue he has good solos
Ruichard Wright: Keyboard: becasue
Neil Peart: Drums its Neil Fucking Peart People. -_-
Roger Waters: Bass

[Sugaree]

Heres mine:
Freddie Mercury:Vocals: You cant beet him when it comes to vocals

Bjork, Thom Yorke, Billie Holiday. Beat him.

Nick Mason: Keyboard: becasue

>Nick Mason
>keyboards

u wot m8

Neil Peart: Drums its Neil Fucking Peart People. -_-

I love Neil. I've seen him in concert. But he's not the best I've heard. Anything outside of Rush, Peart just falls short. He works best in small groups.

Clive Deamer (Portishead) - Percussion
Gavin Harrison (Porcupine Tree) - Drums
Marco Minnemann - Additional drums/percussion
Beth Gibbons (Portishead) - Vocals
Johnny Greenwood (Radiohead) - Guitar, keyboard, samples
Steven Wilson (Porcupine Tree) - Guitar, keyboard, hammered dulcimer
Keith Emerson - Keyboard, organ
Tony Levin - Bass, stick

[Professional Russian]

Bjork, Thom Yorke, Billie Holiday. Beat him.

Not really. Freddie had one of the highest vocal ranges and amazing voices.

[Sugaree]

Not really. Freddie had one of the highest vocal ranges and amazing voices.

His vocal range was above average, but not the highest. He still couldn't reach C# to save his life.

[Professional Russian]

His vocal range was above average, but not the highest. He still couldn't reach C# to save his life.

Who the hell can hit C#

[Sugaree]

Who the hell can hit C#

Thom Yorke and Bjork.

[Professional Russian]

thom yorke and bjork.

i think freddie is better thats why i chose him.

[Antagonist]

Hmmmm.

M. Shadows; vocals. I mean come on. He's amazing.
Joey Jordinson; the best drummer alive today c:
Jerry Cantrell; guitarist. Lead guitarist of Alice In Chains for those of you who don't know.
Mick Thompson; guitarist. For those intricate solos.
Bass; Sean Yseult. One of my all time favorite bassists ever. It's a girl. And she kicks ass.

[Fractured Silhouette]

Vocals: Benjamin Nominet
Vocals: Neema Askira
Guitar: Jhon Browne
Guitar + Programing: Thomas “Drop” Betrisey
Base Guitar: Ryan Martinie
Drums/Percussion: Dan "Loord" Foord

You've probably heard of none of these people, which is sad. But nonetheless, these guys would make one hell of a progressive metal band.

[Daracon]

Rob Halford : Vocals, his range is quite amazing and he revolutionized heavy metal.
Randy Rhoads: Guitarist, He wasn't the greatest but he is one of my favourite guitar players
Cliff Burton: Bass, He could make a bass sound like a guitar, he was just epic
John Bonham: Drums, he is a drumming God, his rhythm and precision were quite amazing

[ArsenicCatNip]

Vocals: Fred Durst(because he's got dope, straight stupid rhymes)
Guitar: Mick Thomson playing a midi guitar(this is an experimental group)
Bass: Gene Simmons(because why the hell not?)
Drums: Ringo Starr(name me a more talented drummer; you can't)
On the DJ: Merzbow scratchin slick noise
They'll create a black hole of terribleness

[Sugaree]

Drums: Ringo Starr(name me a more talented drummer; you can't)

Gavin Harrison
Mike Portnoy
Neil Peart
Danny Carey
Bill Bruford

Your turn.

[Aves]

Drums: Ringo Starr(name me a more talented drummer; you can't)

Haha, that's actually pretty funny man. It's as if you don't listen to drum parts to save your life.

What's funny is a band I would love to hear would be:
Patrick Stump: Vocals/Rhythm Guitar
Tim McIlrath: Lead Guitar/Backing Vocals
Joe Principe: Bass
Andy Hurley: Drums

Why is it funny, 2 members of Fall Out Boy and 2 from Rise Against.

[Professional Russian]

Drums: Ringo Starr(name me a more talented drummer; you can't)


Neil Peart. Ringo Dont have shit on Neil Peart

[ArsenicCatNip]

Gavin Harrison
Mike Portnoy
Neil Peart
Danny Carey
Bill Bruford

Your turn.

I was being sarcastic haha:lol: If you noticed I only named bland musicians

[Stryker125]

Vocals - Max Bemis, Jason Butler, Anthony Green or Eric Nally (they're all amazing vocalists, and have killer stage presence to top it off)

Guitar - Max Bemis. The dude writes infectious guitar parts and awesome solos, but never takes away from the song, or comes across as a showoff. (Dallas Green would also be a great choice)

Guitar - Vic Fuentes. Also writes great parts, great feel, plus I think the guitar play between Vic and Bemis would be orgasmic.

Bass - Jaime Preciado or Adam Siska. Both solid bassists. Plus they're the first two to pop into my head..

Drums - Coby Linder, Luke Holland, Mike Fuentes, Aaron McVeigh. All great drummers who manage to be dynamic and powerful without over doing it.


Max Bemis, Coby Linder, and Adam Siska are from the band Say Anything.

Vic and Mike Fuentes, and Jaime Preciado are from the band Pierce The Veil.

Luke Holland started out posting covers on youtube, and is now in the band The Word Alive.

Eric Nally and Aaron Mcveigh are from the band Foxy Shazam.

Dallas Green (formally of Alexisonfire) is also known as City And Colour.

[Sugaree]

I was being sarcastic haha:lol: If you noticed I only named bland musicians

I recognized the /mu/ in you from the get go :P

[ArsenicCatNip]

I recognized the /mu/ in you from the get go :P

Oh yea! I've been browsing for about 2 years now :D

[Syvelocin]

Let's go:

Tuomas Holopainen - keyboards and lyricist
John 5 - Guitar
Brian Viglione - Drums
Twiggy - Bass for lack of a better knowledge of bass players
And let's grab Georgia Train who probably no one knows for vocals.

I really have no fucking clue. I'm better at casting book-movies.

Who the hell can hit C#

I can. But I'm a girl.