Log in

View Full Version : Can a highschool hold back credit due to misbehavior?


justalovestruckteen
August 23rd, 2012, 01:44 AM
(Not sure if this belongs here..)

So in my sophomore year, I had this super bad English teacher with crazy belifs like, "When citing sources, you can't use a .com." Even if it's fox news.com or that stuff. She says it could be anyone using a .com domain. Weird that people can purchase .org domains too and put inaccurate info. Good thing she at least knows Wiki can sometimes be unreliable. Also, when I underlined a movie tittle, she said it had to be quotes when I know it's not true.
So anyways, my english teacher was pretty bad. Half of the stuff she teaches are stuff from elementary school. But the one thing I learned from her is ionic pentameter (which wasn't even required for us to learn but anyways).
She always comes to class after the tardy bell (if she was a student she will be late). I understand that it was her first year teaching, but I still longed to be in another class where the teacher is a little more experienced. I talked to my counselors about my problems, but they refused to send me to another class because all the other english teachers are males. (Ok weird story, I have a past for having feelings fro my teachers. XD. I don't do that anymore though, but it's extremely weird that the band teacher is a male, jortc instructors are males and my history teacher was a male. Their argument is that they are not "classes" but "programs")
Heartbroken and sad, I tried to keep in my feelings of sadness inside. In my school, I am in the special education program as emotionally disturbed.
One day though, I couldn't keep it in any longer. After another thing my teacher done. (I believe it was mostly a misunderstanding on my part cause I didn't hear her. ugg memory is blurry) I stormed out of the class and into the lunch room. I pushed a person out of my way (they weren't hurt, it was just like a shove), than when a teacher tried to grab me so I can stop walking, I turned around and punched her.
( I really feel bad about it. Those two didn't do anything. The student in fact is someone I know as a cool person and the teacher is awesome.)
I said sorry afterwards, I am quiet lucky they forgive me. :).
Of course that doesn't mean I won't get any consequences, I understand what I did was wrong.
So anyways, the school usually sends people to another school for in school suspension for bad behavior for 10 days. Usually, people get in there for drug use on campus. Since it was my first offense, they gave me 5 days, (my birthweek I may add, though my mom gave me our school b-day party the week after. My mom is great like that. :))
But due to my emotional disturbance status, they can't give me more than 10 days though I saw an old classmate with ADHD the long term program.
Anyways moving on. I did my time and the teachers there were great, They appreciate me for not doing a single thing wrong the whole time I was there. I like them :). It wasn't as bad as the school suspension I got when I was in 8th grade where they don't let you do anything. This ones make you at least do work and have candy :).
I am going out of topic a bit so I'll get to my problem. So I passed my English class even with a crummy teacher, but now the school decides to hold back my english credit due to the situation above. Can they legally (our public school system is American run) do that? Even though I was punished and everything?
They said that I can earn it back if I behave for the whole school year. (Not a problem as long as they don't give me an incompetent teacher that doesn't know what she's doing.), but it makes me wonder if they can legally do it.
(I have known for a fact I did not fail, because my school schedule says I have Jr English the whole school year. They would give me the class again if I have failed.)
Also, for the whole situation above, did my school did the right thing? (If it's not right I could get a case worker or something.)

Skyhawk
August 23rd, 2012, 02:49 AM
It depends on the school's policies.

PinkFloyd
August 23rd, 2012, 02:57 AM
Well I'm not big in leagal shit like that but you passed to class fair and square. What they did was basically like saying "Well your army has better guns... so we win for unfairness.") Do you get what I'm saying?

azorne
August 23rd, 2012, 06:35 AM
I doubt, though it varies from state to state.

StoppingTime
August 23rd, 2012, 07:56 AM
Not only does it depend on the state, but it depends on the individual high school as well.
I would recommend reading through the student handbook, if you have it, and skip to the section discussing punishment, and ISS's.
I don't know whether this was the right thing for the school to do, seeing as I don't know if it was legal or not, but presuming it is allowed, than yes, I do. If you physically harm a teacher, I think there needs to be a punishment for that.

justalovestruckteen
August 23rd, 2012, 09:07 PM
Not only does it depend on the state, but it depends on the individual high school as well.
I would recommend reading through the student handbook, if you have it, and skip to the section discussing punishment, and ISS's.
I don't know whether this was the right thing for the school to do, seeing as I don't know if it was legal or not, but presuming it is allowed, than yes, I do. If you physically harm a teacher, I think there needs to be a punishment for that.

There was already a punishment. I did my time. I don't know if they could bring it up from last year. (punish once last year, another this year for the same thing)
Thanks everyone for the replies. I looked into it, and there is no information stated about it in the student handbook. There was information about earning credit by time (I think that mostly is about make up work, though this situation is like earning a grade back by behavior when I already passed. I feel like it's a bribe in a way.) but nothing about behavior affecting grades or anything like that.
I did learn that my school doesn't follow it's own handbook rules. XD. But it's little stuff like teachers can't allow students to grade test, or gift deliveries can't be made during class time, teachers can't leave the class even with a teacher aid, and even that every student has to sign a contract agreeing to the rules.