Log in

View Full Version : Student Arrested For Ranking Female Classmates On Facebook


ShyGuyInChicago
May 10th, 2011, 04:48 PM
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/05/10/student-arrested-for-rank_n_860115.html

In January, a Oak Park-River Forest High School student found himself in hot water after publishing a list of 50 of his female peers, ranking them based on physical attributes and reported sexual conquests. The list was circulated on Facebook, and on Monday, the teen was arrested.
The unnamed student reportedly ranked the girls on a 10-point scale based on facial features, a 5-point ranking for various body parts and a ranking of whether their "stock" is up or down, according to the Chicago Sun-Times. Girls were also given nicknames like "The Designated Drunk" and "The Amazing Bisexual." The list was circulated on Facebook, and in the halls on photocopied flyers.
The school suspended the 17-year-old for a week in January, and said at the time they were considering further disciplinary action. On Monday, he was arrested in his Oak Park home and charged with misdemeanor disorderly conduct.
TribLocal reports:
The charges were levied with cooperation from the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office and Oak Park police said there will not be any additional charges. “After the conclusion of the investigation, this case is closed,” said Cmdr. LaDon Reynolds.
The list, which was full of misogynistic language and racial slurs, led some students to start a campaign against sexism.
"You're walking down the halls, looking at people, and you don't know what they might have read about you or what might have been said about you," junior Zoe McNeil told the Chicago Tribune in January. Another junior, Julia Levy, bristled at the student body's reaction: "Overwhelmingly, people found that it was no big deal or just boys being boys."

Perseus
May 10th, 2011, 05:51 PM
He shouldn't have been arrested for that. That's over the top.

JunkBondTrader
May 10th, 2011, 06:28 PM
They really arrested this jackass? Can't say I'm all that sorry for him but I wouldn't say he's a criminal either.

Still, I feel for whoever ranked at the bottom of that list...

ShyGuyInChicago
May 10th, 2011, 07:53 PM
I think that what the kids did was sexual harassment. So arresting him was justified in my opinion.

tpzy94
May 10th, 2011, 07:55 PM
wow thats stupid...he shouldn't have talked about the sexual stuff though

TheFountainGoddess
May 10th, 2011, 10:43 PM
Let him do whatever the fuck he wants. Yeah, it's mean, but if you don't want to see it, then don't look at it.

Korashk
May 10th, 2011, 11:19 PM
Libel is a legitimate crime. Although I don't know the SOP doe dealing with infractions.

Sith Lord 13
May 10th, 2011, 11:24 PM
Libel is a legitimate crime. Although I don't know the SOP doe dealing with infractions.

Can they prove it's libel? I don't see how. I think it's over the top.

Korashk
May 10th, 2011, 11:54 PM
Can they prove it's libel? I don't see how.
"The Amazing Bisexual"; "The Designated Drunk". The nicknames part of the supposed rankings almost literally screams "Zomg, I want to be sued for defamation of character."

Which is likely a more accurate charge/civil complaint.

Roses_Are_Yellow
May 12th, 2011, 08:57 PM
Isn't that how facebook started? The creator of facebook , along with his friends created a website where they hacked in to the data base of the college's around them, got the photo's on the college girls ID's, then put it on a site to rate how hot they were.


I don't think it's right that he was rating how hot a girl was...but is that a little extreme?

(cross that out please)


Never mind, I didn't read that carefully..... I take back everything I said, that's just messed up what he did.

CaptainObvious
May 13th, 2011, 11:59 PM
"The Amazing Bisexual"; "The Designated Drunk". The nicknames part of the supposed rankings almost literally screams "Zomg, I want to be sued for defamation of character."

Which is likely a more accurate charge/civil complaint.

criminal libel is extraordinarily difficult to prove, and this is unlikely to qualify. i find it such a joke that they arrested him, and i am starting to become rather annoyed at what i see as the backlash over all the teen suicides etc. yeah, we need to fix bullying, but capriciously punishing individual cases of bullying way beyond what's reasonable isn't the way - that requires a change in attitude, which arrest doesn't help, beyond being a ridiculous response to this.

Infidelitas
May 15th, 2011, 05:55 PM
Thats a bloody horrible thing to do. Yet another thing to ruin girls self esteem

Random3r
May 15th, 2011, 06:08 PM
haha i know loads of people that put stuff like " like this and i will rate you on looks etc " on facebook i dont think i would be so fussed if i was any of them girls,, if the internet has such an impact on them that it is making them upset or what ever then dont go bashing houndreds of photos on like all the girls i know do,, i would stick up for anyone that is being bullied and i think this guy sounds to be a bit of a prick and obvioustly aint getting any of the girls orelse he wouldent be spending all his time thinking about them?? :P